Content4 min read
How to Write Headlines That Are Not a Guess
A headline has four jobs and most only do one. Here is a method, the patterns that work, and how to test a line before publishing it.
Knowing how to write headlines is mostly knowing what a headline is for. It has to do four things at once: say what this is, say who it is for, give a reason to continue, and survive being cut short. Most headlines do the first and hope. The method below is how to do all four deliberately.
How to write headlines: the method
1. Write the boring version first. Plainly, what the thing is. "How to compress an image for Instagram." This is your baseline and it is already better than most headlines, because it is unambiguous.
2. Add the specific. A number, a constraint, a surprising detail. "…without visible damage." Specificity is what separates a headline from a category label.
3. Cut every word that is not doing work. Adverbs first, then hedges, then anything already implied.
4. Check where it gets cut. The most common headline failure is not being bad — it is being truncated before the good part.
FreeMentioned in this article
Headline & Title AnalyzerScore a title, and get the specific edits that would improve it.The analyzer scores clarity, emotion, power words and length, which turns a vague "does this read well?" into something you can act on.
FreeMentioned in this article
Social Media Character CounterOne box, every platform’s limit, and exactly where each one cuts you off.Patterns that keep working
| Pattern | Example shape |
|---|---|
| How to X without Y | How to compress an image without visible damage |
| The N things that X | The five settings that suppress a video |
| X, and why Y | Shorts monetization, and why the RPM is lower |
| What X actually does | What YouTube tags actually do |
| X: the arithmetic | How much YouTubers make: the arithmetic |
These are not formulas to fill in mechanically. They work because each one promises a specific kind of payoff — an exclusion, a count, an explanation — and a reader who wants that payoff knows immediately.
What to avoid
- Curiosity with no substance. "You won't believe what happened next" is a promise
that the content cannot keep, and it is punished by everything that measures whether people stayed.
- Cleverness that obscures. A pun that hides the subject costs you every reader who
was searching for the subject.
- The category as a headline. "Instagram Tips" is a folder name.
- Front-loading your brand. The first words are the most valuable ones.
Where the truncation falls
Different everywhere, and the cut is what decides whether the good half is seen:
- YouTube title length — about 70 characters in search,
fewer in a sidebar.
- Where LinkedIn puts See more — two or three lines.
- Instagram caption length — about 125 characters.
- A search result — roughly 580 pixels, which is not a character count.
Front-loading is the answer to all of them.
Writing five and picking one
The habit that improves headlines faster than any technique: never publish the first one. Write five, pick one, and the fifth is almost always better than the first because the first four exhausted the obvious.
This costs about four minutes and it is the highest-return four minutes in publishing. The reason is not mystical - the first headline you write is a description of what you made, because that is what is in your head. The fifth is a description of what a reader gets, because by then you have run out of ways to describe your own work.
A useful forcing function is to write the five in different shapes: one plain, one with a number, one that names the exclusion, one that poses the question a reader would ask, and one that states the surprising conclusion. Then pick, or take the best half of two.
Testing a headline in ten seconds
Read it to someone who does not know the subject and ask what they think it is about. If they hesitate, or if their answer is a category rather than a specific, the headline is not working yet.
The second test: would you click it if you had not written it? Honest answers here are rare and valuable. The same discipline applies to the line that closes a piece — see call to action examples.
Case matters less than people think, but consistency does — see title case for which convention to settle on.
FreeMentioned in this article
Text Case ConverterEleven casings at once, each one a click away from your clipboard.The wider question of what to write about at all is upstream of the headline: YouTube keyword research and a content calendar that survives a week. Nielsen Norman Group's research on how people read online is the honest account of why front-loading matters.
How do I write a good headline?
Write the plain version, add one specific detail, cut every word not doing work, then check where it truncates on the platform it is for.
How long should a headline be?
Short enough that the important half survives truncation - which is usually well under the platform's stated limit.
Do numbers in headlines work?
Specific numbers do, because they promise a defined amount of content. Round numbers chosen for effect are less convincing.
Should I use clickbait?
A promise the content keeps is not clickbait. A promise it does not keep is punished by every metric that measures whether people stayed.
Score a line rather than guessing at it: headline analyzer.
Put it to work
Tools for the job you just read about
Free to run, most of them without an account.
FreeContent
Headline & Title Analyzer
Score a title, and get the specific edits that would improve it.
Analyze →
FreeContent
Social Media Character Counter
One box, every platform’s limit, and exactly where each one cuts you off.
Count characters →
FreeContent
Text Case Converter
Eleven casings at once, each one a click away from your clipboard.
Convert →
FreeContent
Jargon & Acronym Detector
The words that make sense to you and not to whoever just arrived.
Detect →
FreeContent
Sentence Rhythm Analyzer
Why a draft with nothing wrong with it still reads flat.
Analyze →
FreeContent
Crutch Phrase Finder
The phrases you use every time, which you are the last to notice.
Find →1 runs
Keep reading
More from the blog
Content5 min read
Episode Title Format: Naming a Series Without Losing the Title
A series prefix is a fixed cost paid on every episode forever, chosen when episode one is the only thing that exists and the prefix still looks tidy.
Content4 min read
Preheader Text: The Half of Your Email Preview Nobody Writes
Leave the preheader empty and every inbox fills it from the first text in your email — usually a link nobody clicks. It is the cheapest fix in email marketing.
Content5 min read
What to Put in a Pinned Comment
The pinned comment is the only part of a published video you can still edit. That is what it is for: the things that change, and the thing you got wrong.